The New Yorker Pizza!! What can I say! Some of the best pizza in Petaluma! Depending on whether you want thin or thick pizza! For deep dish I recommend Old Chicago!!!!! But for thin crust with a really good sauce The New Yorker is the best bet! Also. If you make your own pizza the New Yorker will sell you their pizza dough! I've bought their dough many many times to make great pizzas in my pizza oven! I also love chatting with the owner who is from Sicily! I'm full Italian from 2 different regions but we always have lots to compare. Ciao! La Vita E Bella!! Old school Italian decor in the restaurant also!